High superintendent pay fuels debate over Illinois school consolidation

High superintendent pay fuels debate over Illinois school consolidation

Spread the love

(The Center Square) – A new Illinois Policy Institute report reignites debate over how schools are run and how much top administrators are paid, but one national education expert warns district consolidation could make things worse, not better.

The report shows the 10 highest-paid superintendents in Illinois earned over $4.2 million in 2024, with many overseeing only one or two schools.

Nearly half of the state’s 866 districts serve fewer than three schools, a structure the institute says drives up administrative costs and taxes.

But education policy expert Tony Kinnett, a former teacher and administrator, says Illinois may be missing the mark.

“While I understand the desire to consolidate and shift a larger number of students and buildings under one larger superintendent salary, that is not a panacea for fixing education practices,” Kinnett told The Center Square. “And in the particular case of Illinois schools, it wouldn’t actually improve student outcomes just by consolidating districts under a unitary measure.”

House Bill 2966, signed Aug. 15, allows the State Board of Education to fund district reorganization studies.

Illinois Policy’s data show big pay gaps with little correlation to results.

Rich Township’s superintendent earned $423,000 in 2024 while just 10% of students read proficiently and 4% met math standards. At Stevenson High in Lincolnshire, the superintendent made $387,000 with over 70% proficiency in both subjects.

Chicago Public Schools CEO Pedro Martinez, overseeing 600 schools and 300,000 students, ranked 19th in pay. In 2024, 30.5% of CPS students in grades 3-8 met reading proficiency standards on the state exam.

Illinois Policy justifies its call for consolidation by noting that, “without a consistent compensation” system for superintendents, their hefty salaries ultimately “burden taxpayers, students and teachers alike.”

Supporters of district consolidation say merging administrations could reduce these high costs and redirect funds to classrooms, noting that Illinois has the highest property taxes in the nation while other states with larger districts spend less on administration.

Kinnett said bureaucracy, not district size, is the problem.

“As someone who both taught and later served as an administrator in the smallest and largest school districts in the state of Indiana, and have advised on a number of school board audits around the country, I can say that consolidation and deconsolidation are often just maneuvers used to shift problems that are growing or already present in a district,” said Kinnett.

Kinnett suggested that Illinois would benefit more from breaking school districts into independent, charter-style systems similar to Louisiana’s model.

“I was the science director over multiple schools in the Indianapolis Public School system, a role created to manage a large number of high schools, middle schools, and elementary schools all operating under one unified district,” said Kinnett.

While both Kinnett and the Illinois Policy Institute agree Illinois spends too much on administration and too little on students, they sharply differ on solutions. Kinnett’s prescription is choice and decentralization, not consolidation.

“Consolidation doesn’t necessarily assist in general bloat. You just move some superintendent salaries among new administrative staff members,” said Kinnet. “It’s a decent idea, but I very much disagree with the Illinois Policy’s assertion that consolidation is a great measure and always improves performance. I think that’s a blanket sweep that may sound nice to get a point across, but I very much doubt that’s the best solution here.”

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

$55.9 billion budget includes new taxes, 'no property tax relief'

$55.9 billion budget includes new taxes, ‘no property tax relief’

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The Illinois General Assembly has voted to approve a record-high budget for fiscal year 2027, with new...
Illinois to require bell-to-bell student phone ban in public schools

Illinois to require bell-to-bell student phone ban in public schools

By Sean Reed | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Legislation to ban the use of cell phones by students from bell-to-bell officially passed both chambers in...
Election 2026: Stumps heavy with economy, crime in U.S. Senate race

Election 2026: Stumps heavy with economy, crime in U.S. Senate race

By Alan WootenThe Center Square Democrat and fifth decade politician Roy Cooper’s campaign to succeed Sen. Thom Tillis, flipping one of 53 seats in the U.S. Senate, is locked in...
Quintuple fatal in Virginia renews focus on English language in CDL licensures

Quintuple fatal in Virginia renews focus on English language in CDL licensures

By Alan WootenThe Center Square Jing Dong, a U.S. citizen after immigrating from China, will be charged with involuntary manslaughter in the quintuple fatal crash early Friday morning, State Police...
Everyday Economics: Jobs report to test how long consumers can keep carrying economy

Everyday Economics: Jobs report to test how long consumers can keep carrying economy

By Orphe DivounguyThe Center Square The jobs report is the main event this week. But the real question is bigger than payrolls. Can household spending keep holding up when the...
Congress returns to backlog of must-pass legislation

Congress returns to backlog of must-pass legislation

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square After leaving town for a week without sending a key immigration enforcement funding package to President Donald Trump’s desk, Congress returns Monday to a backlog...
Climate science without a notorious worst-case scenario

Climate science without a notorious worst-case scenario

By Morgan SweeneyThe Center Square The United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change threw out one of its most extreme emissions scenarios last week, a major development in climate science...
Illinois Quick Hits: Housing, megaprojects take backseat to budget talks

Illinois Quick Hits: Housing, megaprojects take backseat to budget talks

By Sean Reed | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Top Democrat leaders in the Illinois legislature met with Gov. J.B. Pritzker late Friday behind closed doors...
Taxpayer watchdog calls for accountability after helicopter prom controversy

Taxpayer watchdog calls for accountability after helicopter prom controversy

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A taxpayer watchdog is calling for a potential criminal investigation after allegations surfaced that a suburban...
Proposed $250 bill could be a boon for drug cartels, experts warn

Proposed $250 bill could be a boon for drug cartels, experts warn

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square A proposal to create the largest U.S. currency denomination in more than 50 years could unintentionally benefit drug cartels, money launderers and tax cheats, according...
Iowa voters head to the polls for fierce races

Iowa voters head to the polls for fierce races

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square Voters in Iowa will head to the polls Tuesday to elect candidates in several high-profile primary races that will be watched across the country. Many...
Frankfort School District 157-C.1

Frankfort 157-C Considers Five-Minute Public Comment Limit for Smaller Crowds

Frankfort School District 157-C Board of Education Meeting | April 21, 2026 Article Summary: The Frankfort School District 157-C Board of Education on April 21, 2026, reached consensus to extend...
Screenshot 2026-05-23 at 7.23.02 PM

District 210 Transportation Update Details Fuel Swings, New Bus Safety Technology

Lincoln-Way Community High School District 210 Meeting | May 21, 2026 Article Summary: Lincoln-Way District 210 Transportation Director Andy Rezer told the board on Thursday, May 21, 2026, that fuel...
Speakers object to transgender athletes in girls sports

Speakers object to transgender athletes in girls sports

By Madeline ShannonThe Center Square As state track and field championships commenced Friday at Buchanan High School in Clovis, Calif., protesters set up across the street to take aim at...
Taxpayers group, economist praise Pratt's plan for homelessness in LA

Taxpayers group, economist praise Pratt’s plan for homelessness in LA

By Chris WoodwardThe Center Square Critics may not care for Los Angeles mayoral candidate Spencer Pratt’s plan to deal with the drug-addicted homeless population, but a taxpayers organization and an...