Judge’s questions during IL gun ban arguments gives rights advocates ‘hope’

Judge’s questions during IL gun ban arguments gives rights advocates ‘hope’

Spread the love

(The Center Square) – With Illinois’ gun ban now in the hands of a three judge panel of the federal appeals court, some are plotting out what’s next.

Monday’s oral arguments featured challenging questions from Judge Amy St. Eve for both sides.

“Why haven’t you waived or forfeited that legislative fact argument by not raising it until your reply brief?” St. Eve asked the attorney defending the state law during oral arguments.

“You said 14 to 18 million legally own them for legal purposes, self-defense. But there are also these statistics on the other side. Does that factor in with the nuanced approach or the societal concerns?” St. Eve later asked plaintiffs arguing against the law.

St. Eves is new to the panel after Diane Wood, who ruled against the plaintiffs in 2023, retired. The other judges on the panel split in 2023, Judge Michael Brennan with the plaintiffs and Judge Frank Easterbrook with the state.

Gun rights advocate Todd Vandermyde said it’s hard to tell which way the case goes with St. Eve on the panel.

“We went in there expecting to lose. We walked out of there with hope that, you know, that St. Eve was being reasonable and honest in her questions,” Vandermyde told The Center Square.

The district judge found the law unconstitutional last year after a four-day bench trial and thousands of pages of evidence and testimony.

The state appealed to the Seventh Circuit. The U.S. Department of Justice filed in support of the plaintiffs and against the state. But with a new three-judge appeals panel, Vandermyde said anything is possible.

“I was with some other guys that have been involved in the case, and we all kind of came to the conclusion that it’s 50/50 on a crapshoot and it all centers around what does St. Eve do,” Vandermyde said.

Dan Eldridge with Federal Firearms Licensees of Illinois said having the U.S. Department of Justice on their side is good for them.

“If we lose, that means the solicitor general, John Sauer, would petition for cert with the Supreme Court,” Eldridge told The Center Square. “The solicitor general generally gets deference from the Supreme Court on cert petitions, and that would really, really increase the likelihood that we get shoved to the front of the line with the Supreme Court.”

It’s unclear when the appeals court will make their ruling.

⚠️ Flood Advisory issued June 17 at 3:10PM CDT until June 17 at 6:15PM CDT by NWS Chicago IL
⚠️ Flood Watch issued June 17 at 12:53PM CDT until June 17 at 9:00PM CDT by NWS Chicago IL
Today Jun 16
Showers And Thunderstorms
72° 59°

Showers And Thunderstorms

💨 20 to 25 mph 💧 94%

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Frankfort Square Park District Logo Graphic

Park Board Plans Multi-Year Athletic Field Improvements

Frankfort Square Park District Meeting | Dec. 1, 2025 Article Summary: Commissioners discussed a long-term strategy to improve drainage and usability at district athletic fields, with the district planning to assume...
Illinois Quick Hits: U.S. rep proposes restriction on housing purchases

Illinois Quick Hits: U.S. rep proposes restriction on housing purchases

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois U.S. Rep. Mary Miller, R-Oakland, has introduced legislation to restrict large institutional investment firms from buying...
IL Republicans call for growing tax base, not raising taxes

IL Republicans call for growing tax base, not raising taxes

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Statehouse Republicans say it is time for Illinois Democrats to focus on growing the tax base instead...
DHS funding bill teeters as Democrats balk over ICE concerns

DHS funding bill teeters as Democrats balk over ICE concerns

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square Congress is racing to advance the last four federal spending bills through the House Rules Committee in time for a floor vote Thursday. But Democratic...
House hearing: Fraud goes far beyond Minnesota

House hearing: Fraud goes far beyond Minnesota

By Elyse ApelThe Center Square The U.S. House Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance heard Wednesday from witnesses on the ongoing Minnesota fraud scandal. Republicans and Democrats on...
Supreme Court hears arguments on Fed firing case

Supreme Court hears arguments on Fed firing case

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments on Wednesday in a case over whether President Donald Trump can immediately remove Lisa Cook, a member of...
More than 1,000 cases of child care overpayments in Illinois over 5 years

More than 1,000 cases of child care overpayments in Illinois over 5 years

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – In the past 5 years, the state of Illinois has found more than 1,000 instances of taxpayer...
Support for religious freedom up 5 points from 2020, reaching a high of 71

Support for religious freedom up 5 points from 2020, reaching a high of 71

By Tate MillerThe Center Square Support for religious freedom grew five points from 2020 to 2025, reaching an all-time cumulative high of 71 points, according to Becket’s seventh annual Religious...
New bill would force DCFS to disclose details on missing children

New bill would force DCFS to disclose details on missing children

By Cat Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – An Illinois state senator has introduced legislation requiring the Department of Children and Family Services to...
WATCH: Pritzker says Trump’s first year a failure; Raoul discusses prosecuting fraud

WATCH: Pritzker says Trump’s first year a failure; Raoul discusses prosecuting fraud

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois in Focus Daily, The Center Square's Greg Bishop discusses some of the...
Illinois Quick Hits: Pritzker wants year-round E15 fuel

Illinois Quick Hits: Pritzker wants year-round E15 fuel

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker is renewing his call for the federal government to mandate year-round sales of...
Report: University diplomas losing value to GenAI

Report: University diplomas losing value to GenAI

By Alan WootenThe Center Square University diplomas are losing value, and 9 of 10 trying to gain them have diminished critical thinking skills because of the impact from generative artificial...
will county board meeting graphic.5

Sanctuary Status Threatens Emergency Management Funding, Draft Report Warns

Article Summary: Will County's proposed federal agenda warns that critical emergency preparedness funding is being withheld due to a federal review of "sanctuary jurisdiction" compliance, leaving the county with only...
frankfort-park-district

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Frankfort Park District for December 9, 2025

Frankfort Park District Meeting | December 9, 2025 The Frankfort Park District Board of Commissioners convened on Tuesday, December 9, 2025, to handle year-end financial business, including the approval of...

WATCH: Reclaiming the Panama Canal could be back on the table

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square Taking back the Panama Canal is “sort of on the table,” President Donald Trump told The Center Square in response to a question regarding comments...