'Liberation Day' reignites D.C. statehood debate

‘Liberation Day’ reignites D.C. statehood debate

As the National Guard begins patrolling the streets of Washington, D.C., after President Donald Trump announced their deployment in support of making the city safer, the move has reignited a debate over the district’s statehood.

Since the president’s Monday announcement, protests have emerged to “keep D.C. free,” after fears Congress could rescind the district’s Home Rule Act, granting it limited autonomy.

In response to Trump’s executive action to declare a crime emergency, or “Liberation Day,” in the district by implementing federal control over the Metropolitan Police Department and deploying the National Guard to patrol, Mayor Muriel Bowser is leading a call to grant the city statehood.

“It’s times like these when America needs to know why your nation’s capital, a place where 700,000 taxpaying Americans live should be the 51st state,” Bowser said on The Breakfast Club.

Trump responded while touring the Kennedy Center on Wednesday, calling the push for statehood by Democrats a power play.

“Statehood is ridiculous. We want to straighten the place out. Statehood is ridiculous. It’s unacceptable. It’s the Democrats that want it, because the Democrats have, you know, about 95% in this little area,” Trump told reporters. “They want to pick up two senators. And it’s not going to happen … And that’s the least of the reasons why … What we want to do is make Washington, D.C. the greatest, most beautiful, safest capital anywhere in the world, and that’s going to happen.”

However, Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, who introduced legislation in February to end the D.C. Home Rule Act, has suggested an alternate plan that could be a political compromise.

Lee proposed the idea of returning much of the land the district occupies to Maryland.

“If the residents of DC want to be part of a state, the solution is *not* DC statehood. Any solution should involve reverting land ceded by Maryland for the creation of DC – excepting only a narrow corridor encompassing the White House, Capitol, & Supreme Court – to Maryland,” Lee posted on X.

He noted historical context and precedence to his proposal, adding that when D.C. was established by Congress in 1790, land was ceded from Maryland and Virginia, creating a diamond-shaped district. In 1846, Congress passed legislation to retrocede the Virginia portion of the land back to the commonwealth, which now comprises much of Arlington and the City of Alexandria.

Lee argues that the district in itself “doesn’t meet the criteria” that has been “historically applied to statehood.”

“Although the Constitution doesn’t specify minimum population or geographic size, our states have been admitted as territories with balanced economies —agriculture, industry, and diverse resources … We have *never* admitted a state that consists of just a single, geographically compact, urban enclave — whether heavily dependent on the federal government…

“DC lacks anything close to the industries, natural resources, opportunities for growth, and amenities found in literally every other state. It’s just a city — one city — and therefore can’t be accorded the status of a sovereign state using the time-honored criteria. More importantly, the Founders quite intentionally created DC as a *neutral* federal district to serve as the seat of the U.S. government under Article I, Section 8,” Lee wrote.

He added that the land return would “give DC residents what they deserve—state-level representation.”

Two states, Vermont and Wyoming have smaller populations than D.C.

The District of Columbia Home Rule Act of 1973 was enacted by Congress and ratified by D.C. voters. The act gave the district residents limited autonomy over local affairs, allowing them to elect local leaders, including mayors and council members.

Despite gaining some control, ultimately, Congress has the authority to manage the nation’s capital, according to Article 1, Section 8, Clause 17 of the U.S. Constitution. The president also has the authority to appoint district judges.

Events

26 Aug
28 Aug
28 Aug
29 Aug
30 Aug
30 Aug 25
30 Aug
30 Aug 25

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WATCH: Illinois State Fair: Affordable fun backed by $140M in taxpayer funding

WATCH: Illinois State Fair: Affordable fun backed by $140M in taxpayer funding

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The 2025 Illinois State Fair is being praised for its affordability and accessibility to families across...
Op-Ed: State lawmakers gut Emmett Till Day bill, expose Illinois’ corruption problem

Op-Ed: State lawmakers gut Emmett Till Day bill, expose Illinois’ corruption problem

By LyLena D. Estabine | Illinois Policy InstituteThe Center Square July 25, 2025, would have marked Illinois’ first Emmett Till Day, a commemoration of the 14-year-old Chicagoan whose 1955 lynching...
Democratic PACs being investigated for bankrolling AWOL Texas House Democrats

Democratic PACs being investigated for bankrolling AWOL Texas House Democrats

By Bethany Blankley | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Democratic political action committees are being investigated by state, and potentially federal, authorities over claims they...
Pritzker: Chicago mayor 'never once called' to oppose pension bill

Pritzker: Chicago mayor ‘never once called’ to oppose pension bill

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker says Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson never called him to oppose a pension bill...
WATCH: Illinois In Focus Daily | Thursday Aug. 7th, 2025

WATCH: Illinois In Focus Daily | Thursday Aug. 7th, 2025

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois in Focus Daily, The Center Square Editor Greg Bishop continues his coverage...
Illinois quick hits: Cook County declares flood disaster; opt-out forms promoted; State Fair begins

Illinois quick hits: Cook County declares flood disaster; opt-out forms promoted; State Fair begins

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Cook County, Chicago declare flood disaster Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson and Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle have issued respective disaster...
WATCH: IL Republican pushes for TX quorum rules that Pritzker hails as ‘hero’ move

WATCH: IL Republican pushes for TX quorum rules that Pritzker hails as ‘hero’ move

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – While Gov. J.B. Pritzker jokes on national TV that Illinois’ congressional maps were drawn by kindergartners, a...
Frankfort Meeting 8.4.25

Frankfort to Implement 1% Grocery Tax, Replacing State Levy to Preserve Revenue

FRANKFORT – Frankfort residents will see no change at the grocery checkout line, but the village will preserve a key revenue stream after the Village Board approved an ordinance Monday...
frankfort village hall graphic logo.1

Frankfort to Sell Vacant Downtown Property Valued at $325,000 for Commercial Redevelopment

FRANKFORT – The Village of Frankfort is officially putting a prime piece of vacant, village-owned land in its historic downtown up for sale, aiming to spur immediate commercial redevelopment. The...
frankfort village hall graphic logo.8

New Sushi Restaurant ‘The Orange Hat’ Approved for Frankfort

FRANKFORT – A new full-service sushi restaurant, The Orange Hat, is set to open in the Hickory Creek Market Place after the Village Board approved a special use permit for...
frankfort village hall graphic logo.7

Village Board Approves Zoning Variances for New Custom Home on Bowen Street

FRANKFORT – The Frankfort Village Board on Monday approved two zoning variances for a new custom home at 50 E. Bowen Street, allowing the builder to use non-masonry siding and...
Meeting-Briefs

Meeting Summary: Frankfort Village Board for August 4, 2025

The Frankfort Village Board met on Monday, August 4, 2025, to address several key ordinances and conduct village business. The board approved a measure to replace the state's expiring 1%...
Fire-Ambulance-Rescue-Logo

Indiana Woman Identified as Victim in Fatal Wilmington-Peotone Road Crash

The Will County Coroner’s Office has officially identified the woman killed in Tuesday’s fatal crash on Wilmington-Peotone Road as 70-year-old Judith L. Stirm of Delphi, Indiana. In a statement, Coroner...
Frankfort-Police-Rescue

Multiple Agencies Rescue Person in Mental Health Crisis from Frankfort Pond

A person experiencing a mental health crisis was safely rescued from a pond near 80th Avenue in Lakeview Estates on Wednesday after a coordinated response by multiple emergency agencies. Frankfort...
Meeting-7.28.25

IT Consultant Urges Green Garden Township to Adopt Modern Cybersecurity Measures

Green Garden Township’s digital infrastructure is vulnerable to cybercrime and requires an immediate overhaul, including adopting a modern, secure email system and multifactor authentication, an IT consultant told the board...